Supreme Court Reflected on Circuit Split on When a Copyright is Enrolled in Fourth Estate v. Wall-Street.com

Categories: Asma Raza

On January 8th, the Supreme Court heard oral contentions in Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corporation v. Wall-Street.com [Case No. 17-571 (Jan. 8, 2019)] to settle a longstanding circuit split on the copyright enlistment essential to a copyright infringement suit.

The Split

The first sentence of Section 411(a) in the Copyright Act states: “[N]o civil action for infringement of the copyright in any United States work shall be instituted until preregistration or registration of the copyright claim has been made in accordance with this title.” The courts of appeals have differ with respect to what accurately this “registration” condition in segment 411(a) requires. Courts applying the “application approach” have held that the condition is met when a copyright proprietor presents every one of the materials required to enlist a work to the Copyright Office. Courts applying the “registration approach,” then again, have held that it is met just when the Copyright Office has really settled on its choice by either denying the application or issuing the endorsement of enlistment. In the case below, the Southern Region of Florida dismissed Fourth Estate’s copyright case against Wall-Street.com, and the Eleventh Circuit asserted, on the grounds that Fourth Estate sued Wall-Street.com in the wake of applying to enroll its copyrights, yet before the Copyright Office acted. Fourth Estate Pub. Benefit Corp. v. Wall-Street.com, LLC, 856 F.3d 1338, 1341 (11th Cir. 2017). The resolution of the circuit split will turn on the Justices’ construction of the statutory phrase “registration . . . has been made.” Explicitly, who, in the statutory plan, “makes” the enrollment: the copyright proprietor (as per Fourth Domain), or the Copyright Office (as indicated by Divider Street.com)? Oral argument seemed to suggest that the Justices found Wall-Street.com’s textual argument had more weight, though some of them expressed reservations about what Congress intended and the practical implications of requiring litigants to have a certificate of registration in hand before filing suit.

The Questions Considered in Fourth Estate

Justice Kagan agreed with Fourth Estate that the term “registration” was flexible enough to encompass both meanings, but noted the parallel structure between the use of “registration has been made” in the first sentence of Section 411(a), and the use of “registration has been refused” in the second sentence: “[Y]ou have these two sentences, they’re in total proximity. They’re both framed in the passive voice. ‘Registration has been refused’ is clearly the registration has been refused by the Register, not by the holder. And so it seems,” Justice Kagan continued, “the only way to read this is that ‘registration has been made’ is by the Register too.” Similarly, Chief Justice Roberts pointed out that “in a situation where you’ve got a registrar . . . the most likely understanding of ‘registration’ is what that person does.”

The Chief Justice, however, also found merit in Fourth Estate’s argument that numerous provisions of the Copyright Act use identical or similar language when referring to the action of the copyright owner. As a result, according to the Chief Justice, both parties’ constructions lead to incongruities in textual meaning throughout the statute.

Justices Kavanaugh and Gorsuch, by contrast, focused their questioning on the policy and practical implications of the parties’ positions. Justice Kavanaugh, in particular appeared to find Wall-Street.com’s textual argument more convincing but seemed concerned that adopting its position could result in serious problems for copyright holders. In a world where artistic works can be quickly and widely distributed over the internet, Fourth Estate argued, requiring a copyright owner to wait until the Copyright Office has acted could lead to delay and the loss of substantive rights. This concern is particularly acute because of the backlog of applications at the Copyright Office; currently applications are processed in 2-15 months. Wall-Street.com’s answer was that Congress and the Copyright Office have provided means to address many of the issues that are likely to come up, including: (1) the Copyright Office’s special handling procedures allowing a pending application critical to litigation to be immediately considered and acted upon by the Copyright Office; (2) pre-registration for artistic works that are not yet finished; and (3) the live broadcast exception in Section 411(c).

Tea Leaves Versus Content

The Justices gave little indication as to how convincing they found either party’s policy arguments. The first rule of statutory interpretation, however, is that if the plain meaning of the text is clear, the inquiry ends. Here, at least two of the Justices acknowledged that the term “registration” is flexible, so the issue may end up turning on how far outside the four corners of Section 411(a) the Court is willing to look to determine its meaning. One of Justice Scalia’s enduring legacies has been the Supreme Court’s increased focus on the primacy of text in statutory construction. With Justice Kavanaugh now on the bench (by all accounts a committed statutory textualist), Fourth Estate’s argument that a pending application is sufficient appears to face an uphill climb with this Court.

If, as anticipated, the “registration” approach prevails, expect to see an increase in the number of special handling filings at the Copyright Office, and a potential new backlog of such applications. If, however, the “application approach” prevails, it could pit copyrightability and registration decisions made by courts against later-issued determinations by the Copyright Office, potentially creating post-litigation disputes.

76 Comments

  1. Good day! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could find a captcha plugin for my comment form?
    I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having difficulty finding one?
    Thanks a lot!

  2. I feel this is one of the such a lot important info for
    me. And i’m satisfied reading your article.
    But want to remark on few normal issues, The web site style is wonderful, the articles
    is in reality nice : D. Excellent process, cheers

  3. We stumbled over here different web page and thought I might check things out.

    I like what I see so now i am following you.
    Look forward to looking over your web page repeatedly.

  4. Cialis Las Palmas

  5. Highly energetic article, I enjoyed that a lot.
    Will there be a part 2?

  6. Thank you, I’ve just been searching for information about this topic
    for a while and yours is the best I’ve discovered so far.
    However, what concerning the conclusion? Are you positive in regards
    to the source?

  7. Great post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed!

    Very helpful info specially the last part 🙂 I care for such information much.
    I was looking for this certain info for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.

  8. Very good information. Lucky me I recently found your website by accident (stumbleupon).
    I’ve book-marked it for later!

  9. I’m extremely pleased to discover this web site.
    I wanted to thank you for ones time for this particularly wonderful read!!
    I definitely enjoyed every little bit of it and i also have you book-marked to see new things on your web site.

  10. If you are going for best contents like myself, simply
    pay a quick visit this site daily for the reason that it presents quality contents, thanks

  11. What a information of un-ambiguity and preserveness of valuable experience about unexpected feelings.

  12. https://buystromectolon.com/ – buy ivermectin for humans

  13. Buy Ciprofloxacin Hydrochloride

  14. Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your web site, how could i subscribe for a
    blog website? The account aided me a acceptable deal.
    I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your
    broadcast offered bright clear concept cheap flights http://1704milesapart.tumblr.com/ cheap flights

  15. Paragraph writing is also a fun, if you know after that you
    can write or else it is complicated to write. quest bars http://j.mp/3jZgEA2 quest bars

  16. You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I
    find this topic to be actually something that I think I would never understand.
    It seems too complex and very broad for me. I’m looking forward for your next
    post, I’ll try to get the hang of it! scoliosis surgery https://0401mm.tumblr.com/ scoliosis surgery

  17. It’s truly very difficult in this active life to listen news on Television, thus I only use web for that purpose, and get the most recent news.

    ps4 https://j.mp/3z5HwTp ps4 games

  18. Cialis Est Il Vraiment Efficace

  19. http://prednisonebuyon.com/ – ordering prednisone from canada

  20. Viagra Generico Nombre

  21. Zithromax Alternative

  22. Acquisto Levitra Da Scaricare

  23. Canada Prescriptions No

  24. Hello to all, how is all, I think every one is getting more from this web site, and your views are fastidious in favor of new viewers.|

  25. Anadian Companies Selling Ciailis

  26. Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thank you so much,
    However I am encountering problems with your RSS.
    I don’t understand why I cannot join it. Is there anybody
    having similar RSS issues? Anybody who knows the solution can you kindly respond?

    Thanks!!

  27. Thank you a lot for sharing this with all folks you really recognize what you are speaking about! Bookmarked. Kindly also visit my web site =). We can have a link alternate contract among us|

  28. Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written article. I will be sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll certainly comeback.|

  29. If some one needs to be updated with most up-to-date technologies therefore he must be go to see this web page and be up to date every day.|

  30. site it’s big platform prohibited things. For execution shopping on trading platform hydra v3 site on any day takes many users, for input you need to click on the button and confidential implement purchase, and in case you are in 1st once i went to playground before buying product we must register and replenish account. One’s anonymium is our important purpose, which we are with with pleasure we perform.

  31. It’s amazing to pay a visit this web page and reading the views of all colleagues regarding this article, while I am also zealous of getting experience.|

  32. Fastidious answer back in return of this difficulty with solid arguments and explaining everything on the topic of that.|

  33. Hi there, just wanted to tell you, I loved this post. It was inspiring. Keep on posting!|

Leave Comments

Contact Us

Monday – Saturday: 9 am to 6 pm
Sunday: day off